Key Takeaways
- Many break clauses only work if all rent has been paid by the break date.
- Courts apply break conditions strictly, so even a small unpaid sum can make the break fail.
- In October 2026, a tenant’s break was saved because it relied on the landlord’s own invoice.
- Ask your landlord for a full statement of what’s owed well before your break date.
A break clause can be a lifeline if your business needs to move, downsize or close. But if you’re behind on rent, or you’re not sure every bill has been paid, you could find your break fails at the last moment and you’re tied into the lease for years.
A High Court decision in October 2026 shows how fine the line can be. Here, we explain whether you can break a commercial lease if you owe rent, what the latest ruling means and how to protect yourself.
If you’d like to talk through your lease, our commercial lease dispute solicitors offer a free 30-minute video consultation.
Can you use a break clause if you’re in arrears?
It depends on the wording of your lease. Many break clauses come with conditions, and one of the most common is that the rent, or sometimes all sums due under the lease, must be paid by the break date.
If your lease has that condition and you still owe rent on the break date, the break is likely to fail. The lease carries on, and you remain liable for rent until the next break date or the end of the term.
If your break clause has no payment condition, owing rent doesn’t stop the break working. But you’ll still owe the arrears, and your landlord can pursue you for them.
Why do small amounts matter?
The courts apply break conditions strictly. If the lease says all sums must be paid, it means all of them, however small.
Tenants have lost the right to break because of tiny unpaid amounts, such as interest on a late payment they didn’t know was due. In another well-known case, Marks and Spencer v BNP Paribas, the Supreme Court decided that a tenant had to pay a full quarter’s rent in advance to meet its break condition, even though the break date fell part-way through the quarter, and it couldn’t get the extra back.
That’s why it’s essential to check exactly what the condition requires and to make sure everything is paid in good time.
Worried Your Break Clause Could Fail? Talk It Through for Free
A short call is often enough to see where you stand and what to do next.
In your free consultation, we can:
- ✓Check your break clause and its conditions
- ✓Work out exactly what needs paying, and when
- ✓Explain your options if you’re behind on rent
- ✓Give you a clear idea of costs before you commit
What happened in the Sterling House case?
In Sterling House v International Baccalaureate Organisation, decided on 20 October 2026, the lease allowed the tenant to break only if no annual rent or insurance rent was outstanding on the break date.
The tenant asked the landlord’s managing agents for an invoice for the quarter’s rent. The agents invoiced only up to the break date, and the tenant paid that amount. On a strict reading of the lease, the full quarter’s rent was due, so some rent was still unpaid. Then, on the Friday afternoon before the Monday break date, the landlord sent a demand for insurance rent, which the tenant paid the day after the break date.
The landlord argued the break had failed. The court disagreed. It found that the landlord couldn’t rely on the unpaid rent, because the tenant had paid what the landlord’s own agents had asked for. And a demand sent so late didn’t give the tenant a reasonable chance to pay before the break date.
What does the ruling mean for tenants?
It’s good news if your landlord has given you a misleading figure or left a demand until the last minute. But the decision turned on its own facts, and arguments like these are uncertain. Don’t rely on them if you can avoid it.
The safer approach is to make sure the break condition is met in full, so there’s nothing for your landlord to argue about.
How can you protect your break?
If you’re planning to break your lease, start preparing months before the break date:
- Read the break clause carefully. Check the notice period, how notice must be served and every condition.
- Ask for a full statement of account. Request a written statement of everything due, including rent, service charges, insurance and interest.
- Pay in full and in good time. If the lease requires a full quarter’s rent, pay it, even if the break date falls mid-quarter.
- Pay disputed sums under protest. It’s usually better to pay and argue later than to risk the break.
- Check other conditions. Some breaks also require you to give back the premises empty, without any tenant’s belongings or occupiers left behind.
If you can’t pay what’s owed, talk to your landlord early. A negotiated surrender may be possible, and it’s one of several ways to end a commercial lease early.
Speak to a commercial property solicitor about your break clause
Whether you’re planning to break your lease or your landlord says your break has failed, our commercial property solicitors can check your lease, protect your position and challenge a landlord who tries to keep you tied in.
We advise commercial tenants and landlords on lease disputes of every kind, from rent reviews and dilapidations to forfeiture and break clauses.
Please note that this article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. We always recommend speaking to a qualified solicitor for advice tailored to your specific circumstances.
We offer a free 30-minute video consultation to discuss your situation. To arrange it, call 0203 983 5080, email [email protected] or complete the form below. We do not offer Legal Aid.


