Commercial property lease disputes are a common issue for both landlords and tenants. Disagreements can arise at any stage of a lease and often involve significant financial and operational consequences for a business. Whether the dispute relates to rent, repairs or the use of the premises, understanding your rights and options is essential.
In this article, we explore the most common causes of commercial lease disputes, the rights of landlords and tenants and the remedies that may be available. We also explain how to access a free 30 minute consultation with a solicitor if you need advice tailored to your situation.
Common causes of commercial property lease disputes
Many commercial lease disputes arise from disagreements over money. Rent arrears are a frequent issue, particularly during periods of economic uncertainty. Disputes can also arise at rent review, where landlords and tenants may disagree on the market value of the property or the interpretation of the rent review clause.
Service charges are another common source of conflict. Tenants may challenge the scope of works carried out, the reasonableness of costs or whether the charges are permitted under the lease. These disputes often require careful examination of the lease terms and supporting documentation.
Repair and dilapidations disputes are also widespread. At the end of a lease, landlords may claim that the tenant has failed to comply with repairing obligations, while tenants may argue that the works claimed go beyond what the lease requires. The wording of the repair covenant is central to these disputes.
Break clauses and lease termination can also lead to disagreement. Disputes may arise over whether the conditions of a break clause have been met, such as vacant possession or payment of rent. If a break clause isn’t exercised correctly, the lease may continue, with significant consequences for the tenant.
Understanding your rights under a commercial lease
Commercial leases are primarily governed by the terms of the lease itself. Unlike residential tenancies, commercial tenants have fewer statutory protections, making the wording of the lease particularly important.
The lease will set out the rights and obligations of both parties, including rent, repair, insurance, service charges and use of the premises. Understanding these terms is essential when assessing whether a party has breached the lease.
Some statutory protections may still apply. For example, the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 can give business tenants security of tenure, unless the lease has been contracted out of the Act. Whether a lease is contracted in or out can significantly affect a tenant’s rights at the end of the term.
Service charge and repair disputes
Service charge disputes often turn on what the lease allows the landlord to recover. Tenants are generally only required to pay for services and works expressly permitted by the lease. Charges must also usually be reasonable and properly incurred.
Repair disputes can be complex, particularly where properties are older or where there is disagreement about the condition of the premises at the start of the lease. Evidence such as schedules of condition, surveyor reports and photographs can be crucial in resolving these disputes.
Professional advice is often needed to interpret lease obligations and assess whether claimed works or costs are justified.
Rent arrears and landlord remedies
Where a tenant falls into rent arrears, landlords have several potential remedies available to them. The most serious of these is forfeiture, which allows a landlord to bring the lease to an end and regain possession of the property. Forfeiture rights must be exercised carefully and in accordance with the lease and the law.
Landlords may also be able to use Commercial Rent Arrears Recovery, known as CRAR, to recover unpaid rent by instructing enforcement agents. CRAR is subject to strict rules and can only be used for certain types of arrears.
Tenants facing enforcement action may be able to apply for relief from forfeiture, particularly where arrears are paid or there is a genuine dispute about the sums owed. Timing is critical in these situations and early advice can be crucial.
Remedies available to tenants
Tenants involved in commercial lease disputes aren’t without protection. Where charges are unreasonable or not permitted by the lease, tenants may be able to challenge them and refuse payment until the dispute is resolved.
In some cases, tenants may seek declarations from the court to clarify their obligations or the correct interpretation of the lease. Where landlords act unlawfully or in breach of the lease, tenants may also have claims for compensation or injunctive relief.
Negotiation is often an effective remedy. Many commercial lease disputes can be resolved through dialogue, particularly where both parties have an interest in maintaining the commercial relationship.
Remedies available to landlords
Landlords may seek to enforce the terms of the lease through recovery of arrears, service charges or repair costs. This may involve issuing formal demands, commencing court proceedings or exercising rights under the lease.
Where tenants breach user clauses or subletting restrictions, landlords may be able to seek injunctions or damages. In serious cases, forfeiture may be considered, although this is often a last resort given the potential consequences.
Landlords should act proportionately and in accordance with legal requirements to avoid claims of waiver or unlawful action.
Resolving disputes without litigation
Litigation isn’t always the best solution to a commercial property dispute. Negotiation and mediation can often provide quicker and more cost effective outcomes.
Alternative dispute resolution allows parties to explore practical solutions and avoid the uncertainty and expense of court proceedings. This approach can be particularly valuable where parties have an ongoing commercial relationship.
Courts increasingly expect parties to consider alternative dispute resolution before issuing proceedings and failure to do so can have cost consequences.
When court action may be unavoidable
In some cases, court action can’t be avoided. This may be necessary where there is a significant breach of the lease, an urgent need for relief or where attempts to resolve the dispute have failed.
Court proceedings can be costly and time consuming, so it’s important to understand the risks and likely outcomes before proceeding. Early legal advice can help businesses decide whether litigation is justified and how best to protect their position.
Managing commercial lease disputes effectively
Commercial property lease disputes can have serious financial implications, but they are often manageable with the right approach. Understanding the lease, acting early and seeking advice can help both landlords and tenants resolve disputes efficiently and avoid unnecessary escalation.
Please note that this article is for informational purposes only and isn’t a substitute for legal advice. We encourage readers to contact Osbourne Pinner for case specific guidance.
Start with a free 30 minute consultation at our offices or remotely. You can speak to us on a video call or visit our offices. We are based in Harrow, Canary Wharf and Piccadilly Circus. And if you are based in Manchester, our new North based office is close by too. Arrange your consultation by calling 0203 983 5080, emailing [email protected] or using the form below.
