Key Takeaways
- A shareholder can ask the court to wind up a company on the “just and equitable” ground.
- It’s most often used when shareholders are deadlocked or trust has broken down in a small company.
- The court may refuse if there’s a better option, such as an unfair prejudice petition.
- Winding up ends the business, so it’s usually a last resort.
You set up the company with a business partner, as equals. Now you can’t agree on anything, board meetings go nowhere and neither of you can outvote the other. Or you’ve been pushed out of a business you helped build, and the other shareholders won’t buy you out.
When a company is stuck like this, one option is to ask the court to wind it up on the “just and equitable” ground. Here, we explain what just and equitable winding up is, when the court will order it and why it’s usually a last resort.
If you’d like to talk through your situation, our dispute resolution solicitors in London offer a free 30-minute video consultation.
What is just and equitable winding up?
Under the Insolvency Act 1986, the court can order a company to be wound up if it thinks it’s “just and equitable” to do so. Unlike most winding-up petitions, this has nothing to do with the company being unable to pay its debts. The company can be profitable and still be wound up.
A shareholder can bring the petition. If the court makes an order, a liquidator is appointed to sell the company’s assets, pay its debts and share out anything left between the shareholders.
When will the court wind up a company on this ground?
The court has a wide discretion, but the cases tend to fall into a few familiar groups:
- Deadlock. The shareholders or directors are split evenly and can’t make decisions, so the company can’t function.
- Breakdown of trust in a quasi-partnership. Many small companies are really partnerships run through a company. If they were set up on the understanding that each founder would be involved in running the business, and one is excluded, the court may wind the company up.
- Loss of purpose. The company can no longer do what it was set up to do.
- Serious misconduct. For example, those in control have acted dishonestly or ignored the other shareholders’ rights.
The leading case is a House of Lords decision from 1972, Ebrahimi v Westbourne Galleries, where a director-shareholder was removed from the board of a family-style business. The court held it was just and equitable to wind it up, because the relationship of trust it was based on had ended.
Stuck in a Deadlocked Company? Talk It Through for Free
A short call is often enough to see where you stand and what to do next.
In your free consultation, we can:
- ✓Look at your shareholders’ agreement and articles
- ✓Compare winding up with a buy-out or other exits
- ✓Explain the risks of presenting a petition
- ✓Give you a clear idea of costs before you commit
Why is it usually a last resort?
Winding up ends the business. Its goodwill, contracts and staff are usually lost, and the assets may sell for far less than the business was worth as a going concern. That can leave every shareholder worse off.
The court also doesn’t have to make an order if some other remedy is available and the petitioner is acting unreasonably by asking for a winding up instead. In practice, that often means an unfair prejudice petition.
There are practical risks too. Once a petition is presented, the company’s payments and property transfers can be void unless the court approves them. Banks may freeze its accounts, which can damage the business before the case is even heard.
What’s the alternative?
The most common alternative is an unfair prejudice petition under the Companies Act 2006. If the company’s affairs have been run in a way that’s unfairly prejudicial to you as a shareholder, the court can make whatever order it thinks fit. Most often, that means ordering the other shareholders to buy your shares at a fair value.
For many people, a buy-out is a better result than winding up. You get the value of your shares, and the business can carry on. Other options include negotiating a sale, using any exit route in your shareholders’ agreement or articles, or resolving the shareholder dispute by agreement.
Some petitions ask for both remedies. You can ask for unfair prejudice relief and, in the alternative, a winding up, although the court will look closely at whether that’s justified.
What should you do if your company is deadlocked?
- Check the paperwork. Your shareholders’ agreement or articles may include a deadlock clause, a buy-out formula or an exit route.
- Keep records. Note decisions that were blocked, meetings you were excluded from and any changes to how the business is run.
- Get advice early. The right route depends on the facts, and a well-timed letter from a solicitor often brings the other side to the table.
Disputes between shareholders rarely get better on their own, and the longer they run, the more value the business can lose.
Speak to a dispute resolution solicitor about winding up a company
Whether you’re stuck in a deadlocked company or you’ve been pushed out of a business you helped build, our dispute resolution solicitors can explain your options and help you choose the route that protects the value of your shares.
We advise shareholders and directors on disputes of every kind, from unfair prejudice petitions and buy-outs to breaches of directors’ duties.
Please note that this article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. We always recommend speaking to a qualified solicitor for advice tailored to your specific circumstances.
We offer a free 30-minute video consultation to discuss your situation. To arrange it, call 0203 983 5080, email [email protected] or complete the form below. We do not offer Legal Aid.


